Seven players hindsight suggests managers shouldn’t have sold

Quick Reads

Chelsea’s decision to allow Nemanja Matic to join Manchester United in the summer continues to raise plenty of eyebrows – but where does the midfielder rank among this group of transfer regrets?

Matic left Stamford Bridge in order to rejoin former boss Jose Mourinho at United and has played a pivotal role as the Red Devils look to mount a serious title charge this term.

Phil Neville this week lamented Chelsea for allowing Matic, who commanded a £40million transfer fee, to leave, claiming it was “one of the poorest decisions I have ever seen in the Premier League”.

But where does that decision sit among the biggest transfer mistakes? We take a look back at seven players who clubs probably regret selling. Hindsight truly is a wonderful thing.

Eric Cantona

“I don’t know why I love you, but I do.”

Leeds fans would have said the same back, but you probably should mention Cantona’s name in West Yorkshire any more. The forward’s flair, style and downright brilliance rapidly made him a cult figure at Elland Road, where he played a key role in their First Division title win in 1992.

However one man didn’t believe the hype. Leeds manager Howard Wilkinson didn’t like the Frenchman, who joined from Nimes in February 1992, where he had been serving a two-month suspension for throwing a ball at a referee and then proceeding to approach every member of the committee in his disciplinary hearing and calling them an idiot, which, as you may expect, led to an extension of his ban. But that’s another tale altogether.

“Eric likes to do what he likes when he likes – and then f*cks off,” Wilkinson said, but even so his transfer to Manchester United came as a huge shock. Leeds Chairman Bill Fotherby had called up his counterpart at United to ask about the availability of Denis Irwin.

Fortunately manager Alex Ferguson was also in the room at the time, and after dismissing any talk of a sale, instructed his Chairman to ask about the availability of Cantona. Wilkinson didn’t take much convincing, as the Frenchman’s move was completed within days and Leeds supporters were left bereft.

As if his 11 goals in 20 appearances so far that season weren’t enough to warn Leeds, what happened next is no secret. Eric Cantona is a name etched in Premier League history forever.

• • • • 

READ: An epic tribute to Eric Cantona and his incredible impact on Man Utd

• • • • 

Nemanja Matic

“I wouldn’t have let him out of the building, I would have chained him to the training ground walls.” Neville certainly wasn’t holding back when he slammed Chelsea’s sale of 29-year-old Matic this week, after Antonio Conte’s side lost their third successive match with Champions League defeat to Roma.

After gaining his critics following Mourinho’s Stamford Bridge exit, Matic was allowed to leave in the summer and reunite with the Portuguese, who describes him as his “assistant coach”, commanding proceedings on the field.

The 6ft4″ Serb has made 722 passes so far this season – more than any Chelsea player – and has played a part in United keeping eight clean sheets from their 10 Premier League games.

Meanwhile, Conte’s men continue to struggle to recreate the success which led to them lifting the Premier League trophy with a midfield that looks particularly forlorn without Matic holding things together.

Andrea Pirlo

“I think it was the signing of the century,” fellow legend Gianluigi Buffon exclaimed when Juventus signed Italy and AC Milan star Pirlo on a free transfer in 2011.

Those at the San Siro thought his career was over as he won his second Serie A title in 2011, but they had no idea what was coming next.

Pirlo’s performances rapidly turned back around with younger, energetic midfielders such as Claudio Marchisio and Arturo Vidal around him, allowing him to sit and do what is so mesmerising to watch, spreading the ball left or right, forwards or backwards, five yards or 50 yards.

Pirlo’s division-topping 13 assists saw Juventus lift the Serie A trophy, the puppet master completing an astounding 500 more passes than any other player in Italy’s top flight. His four seasons at Juventus saw them claim four Italian league titles, and a Champions League final defeat to Barcelona ended any dreams of a treble to round off a quite excellent stint at Juve.

Kevin De Bruyne

The talent displayed by Genk midfielder De Bruyne was enough to convince Chelsea he was worth a punt, signing him for £7million in January 2012.

Immediately loaned back, he then spent the 2012-13 campaign on loan at Werder Bremen where he scored 10 goals in 34 appearances, yet this was not enough to convince Jose Mourinho, who allowed him to leave for Wolfsburg just two years and three Premier League appearances after his arrival.

Another excellent 18 months in the Bundesliga caught the eye of Manchester City, who splashed out £55million to bring him to the Etihad Stadium in 2015, but it was the arrival of Pep Guardiola which has truly unleashed the genius which lies within the unassuming Belgian, and he now sits among the world’s greatest.

“Of course, he is one of the best, there is no doubt about that,” Guardiola said recently. “When we talk about Messi, maybe he can sit alone in the table, with no-one else allowed. But in the table beside, Kevin can sit there.”

• • • • 

READ: Kevin De Bruyne needs to stop being so bloody good – but we know why he is

• • • • 

Jaap Stam

Europe’s top defender for two years running, the defensive lynchpin of three successive Premier League titles and the famous treble of 1999, and the man who steadied the ship when mainstay Peter Schmeichel retired, you would have thought it crazy to allow someone so important to leave.

However, after just three years at Manchester United, Stam was sold to Lazio for around £16million. Was it the tell-all autobiography? Was it the inconspicuous achilles injury? Or was it just because United needed some extra cash?

The defensive colossus went on to spend five more years playing at the highest level, so nearly claiming a second Champions League title with AC Milan on that famous night in Istanbul. And United struggled to fill an unquestionably huge void.

“Jaap Stam was the one. Without a question, I made a mistake there,” Ferguson said in 2007 as he admitted the biggest error of his United career.

Philippe Coutinho

Rafael Benitez proclaimed Coutinho as “the future of Inter Milan” when he revealed the slight 17-year-old to the Italian media in 2010. However, Benitez’s dismissal a few months later saw the Brazilian fall down the pecking order and into the shadows at the European giants.

He was sold to Liverpool for just £8.5million in 2013, and is now widely regarded as one of the most exciting players in the Premier League, with Barcelona and now PSG both trying to batter down Jurgen Klopp’s door for the talented midfielder’s signature.

Though it would be a tragedy for both Liverpool and the Premier League if a move does materialise in January, as a player with undoubted flair and an eye for something special makes a huge difference to both, even if bosses at Anfield can expect a profit of over £100million.

Mesut Ozil

While Ozil has his doubters at Arsenal, then-Real boss Carlo Ancelotti admitted he made a big error in allowing the German king of assists to join Arsenal in 2013. “I think we made a mistake when we gave him the possibility to leave the club,” he said after shipping Ozil out to make way for Gareth Bale.

His transfer started a war of words between himself and Ancelotti prior to the Italian’s admission, the manager claiming Ozil forced a move to Arsenal, before a month later stating he didn’t have the character to play for Real. The midfielder came back and said Ancelotti never trusted him, to which he responded and claimed Ozil ran away from the challenge, before finally admitting he got it wrong.

Ozil has scored or created a total of 68 goals in 124 Premier League appearances at the Emirates, and love him or hate him, carries an air of brilliance with him wherever he goes.


More from Planet Football

10 players Fergie decided not to sign for Man Utd: Silva, Lampard, Neuer…

How a transfer really happens & how a contract looks – The Secret Footballer

Football Manager simulates who’d win if Chelsea 16-17 faced Chelsea 04-05

Can you name the top Premier League goalscorer for every nationality?

 

Promoted Stories