What happened to Ganso, the goose with too few golden eggs?

In Depth

Less than a decade ago, Santos wonderkids Neymar and Ganso were considered equals — a thrilling duo set to become stars of the Brazilian national team. So what happened to the latter?

Have you noticed how wonderkids often come in pairs?

History is full of them. Playing alongside a young Vincent Kompany was the rough diamond of Anthony Vanden Borre. Lurking in Cristiano Ronaldo’s shadow was the near-mythical figure of Fábio Paím. Bojan Krkić, who went from Barcelona sensation to Stoke backup, was aided then ultimately hampered by his proximity to Lionel Messi.

Among other causes, the phenomenon is sometimes a construct of the media. Once a young player becomes sufficiently popular, a journalist can say “but he’s not as good as this other kid!” and shift a few newspapers.

It makes sense but usually works to the detriment of the second wonderkid.

“At one point, I could do more than [Ronaldo], but I did not have what he had,” a rueful Fábio Paím would later admit, having failed to get his career off the ground. “I had the quality, at least as much as him, but I did not have the rest.”

Sometimes, great players even throw the lesser wonderkids under the bus.

For example, when the world looked expectantly at Brazilian Ronaldo ahead of the 1998 World Cup, O Fenômeno tried to deflect the attention — with some degree of success — to his talented but undisciplined team-mate Denílson.

In the end, only one of the two had a successful career.

• • • • 

READ: Denílson: From the world’s most expensive player to snubbed by Bolton

• • • • 

Another Brazilian to have enjoyed a successful career is Neymar. The 26-year-old, currently the world’s most expensive player, has won titles in Brazil, Spain and France, including the Champions League with Barcelona.

It seems only a matter of time before he wins the Ballon d’Or.

But when Brazilians erect statues of Neymar in a decade’s time, one wonders how many of them will remember Paulo Henrique Ganso, his friend and former team-mate whom a previous generation once considered just as talented.

The goose and the golden boy

The nickname ‘Ganso’ means ‘goose’ in Portuguese. And for a few glorious years, Paulo Henrique Chagas de Lima looked fully capable of laying golden eggs — trophies, if you like — for Santos and Brazil.

After making his Santos debut in 2008, a season before Neymar, Ganso quickly became one of Brazil’s most exciting youngsters.

A composed and intelligent playmaker who could play anywhere across midfield, he was first choice for Santos by the 2009 season.

By 2010 he was laying the first of those golden eggs: the Copa do Brasil (Brazil’s domestic cup), in which he was named Best Player, and the Campeonato Paulista (the São Paulo state championship), in which he was named in the team of the year.

That year, Brazil legend Socrates called Ganso the best player of the current generation.

 

Fans of a similar persuasion clamoured for both him and Neymar to be included in Brazil’s 2010 World Cup squad — though the conservative Dunga ultimately decided against it.

But that small setback didn’t hinder Ganso’s development. Santos regained the state championship over the next two campaigns, and in 2011 scooped an even bigger honour: the Copa Libertadores.

One troubling injury aside, Ganso’s career had started incredibly well.

During this period, Neymar’s ascent was equally dramatic. While Ganso was pulling the strings from midfield, Neymar was scoring bucketloads of goals, including 43 in all competitions over the 2012 campaign.

By the end of that season, a 23-year-old Ganso had a very respectable eight caps for the Brazilian national team. Neymar, however, three years younger, had 27, and was evidently moving ahead of his colleague.

Despite the age gap, Ganso and Neymar were extremely close friends. In fact, Ganso was present at the birth of Neymar’s son and became the child’s godfather.

But as the disparity between their respective abilities began to widen, the media effectively forced Ganso to confront the issue: was he to become a second-class wonderkid like Fábio Paím, doomed to live in the shadow of his more talented friend?

In 2012, an unkind rumour suggested that Ganso was jealous of Neymar’s success.

“The rumour has made me upset because it never happened,” Ganso responded. “It made me upset because people always say there is a jealousy between us.

“But I think if we have that true friendship, like a brother and a friend, it’s because we never let it interfere with anything.”

Troubles after Santos

Despite his success on the pitch, 2012 was a difficult year for Ganso.

In addition to dealing with accusations of jealousy, the playmaker was seeking a move away from Santos, which resulted in fans booing him and calling him a mercenary.

The media proposed one of the two Milan clubs as a possible destination.

In the end, however, Ganso made a much shorter trip, moving across the state to join Sao Paulo, where he replaced the departing Lucas Moura. The fee was around £7million.

“It’s a dream come true,” Ganso said. “Ever since Sao Paulo showed interest in signing me I wanted to get the deal done. I can’t wait to get on the field.”

 

If he really did dream about such a move, then his dreams were less imaginative than those of Socrates, who had envisaged Ganso becoming a world-beater.

Neymar, meanwhile, moved to Barcelona for more than 10 times Ganso’s transfer fee.

Ganso enjoyed limited success at his new club, in terms of both trophies and performances. Although Sao Paulo won the Copa Sudamericana (South America’s secondary continental cup) within three months of his arrival, that was to be his only trophy over four years.

Perhaps more importantly, he failed to earn a Brazil cap after leaving Santos.

His form did improve after a couple of seasons, however, and playing with the likes of Káká, Alexandre Pato and Luís Fabiano in 2014 brought the best out of the playmaker.

So while Ganso no longer appeared to be Neymar-class, the football world began focus on him once more.

Keen observers included Sevilla, who signed him in the summer of 2016.

“I know I have to work hard,” Ganso said. “I come to Sevilla with a will to win titles. At 26 years of age I see myself as prepared to make the jump and do it well.”

Sadly, he fell short.

Ganso went in and out of the team, and in summer 2018 was sent out on loan to Amiens, a small French club who, at the time of publication, sit one point above the Ligue 1 relegation zone.

But if taking a step down to a smaller club might have given the Brazilian a chance to showcase his talents as a big fish in a small pond, the reality has been less positive.

Amiens have struggled to accommodate a player not known for his energy and work rate, and Ganso is again looking for a move. Rumours suggest he could join Fluminense in Rio, his European adventure now a confirmed failure.

At 29, time is not on his side to make amends.

Ultimately, Ganso must take some responsibility for the downturn of his career. The last five years should have been his best, but those eye-catching performances of his early twenties remain his pinnacle.

Nonetheless, any critical judgment of the Brazilian will always be influenced by his personal and professional association with Neymar.

And in that regard, he faces an impossible battle. Neymar’s talents are unparalleled, and Ganso was surely never equipped to achieve comparable success.

A golden goose? Not quite, but not a dead duck either.

By Benedict O’Neill


More from Planet Football

Fábio Paim: The wonderkid Chelsea and Jorge Mendes couldn’t save

Can you name the last 20 players to break the world transfer record?

A forensic analysis of Ronaldo’s display in the 2002 World Cup final

Clarence Seedorf in Brazil: A perfect swansong in his football utopia