Ranking every Man Utd captain of the PL era from worst to best

Manchester United have been blessed with some legendary leaders – but their captains haven’t been too successful in recent years.

Harry Maguire is the current wearer of the armband but it’s rumoured that the defender will be replaced by one of his team-mates before the start of the new season.

Here are the 11 permanent Manchester United captains from the Premier League era, ranked by how well they fared with the armband.

11. Ashley Young

Young regularly took on the leadership duties at United but was permanently given the armband by Solskjaer at the start of the 2019-20 season.

The 37-year-old made just 18 appearances that year after losing his place in the side to Aaron Wan-Bissaka and Brandon Williams and United endured a fairly forgettable trophyless campaign.

Young turned down a new deal at Old Trafford and he lasted just half a season as club captain, ending his nine-year stay at the club to join Inter Milan in 2020.

10. Antonio Valencia

Valencia was an excellent servant to United and captained the club for their Europa League final win over Ajax in 2017.

Jose Mourino named him as the official club captain ahead of the 2018-19 season, but the full-back struggled with injuries and made just nine appearances that year.

United didn’t offer Valencia a contract extension, so he left the club and joined LDU Quito in 2019 after 10 years at Old Trafford.

9. Harry Maguire

Maguire was named captain at Old Trafford in January 2020, just five months after joining the club from Leicester City.

“He’s come in and been a leader in the group,” Ole Gunnar Solskjaer said at the time. “I’ve been, not surprised, but I’ve been impressed by his leadership skills, so Harry will keep on wearing the armband.”

It’s easy to forget now, but Maguire did look a natural fit as Solskjaer’s Red Devils finished runner-up and went unbeaten away from home in the 2020-21 Premier League campaign. Things might have been different were he fit for the Europa League final, too.

Things have suddenly and sharply gone downhill since then, with the England’s international glum demeanour in post-match telling the story of their disastrous form in 2021-22 – arguably their worst season of the Premier League era.

He’s now a firm bench warmer, with United making it clear that he’s up for sale.

8. Michael Carrick

After Wayne Rooney’s departure in 2017, Carrick became the longest-serving player in United’s squad and the midfielder was named the new club captain.

The 38-year-old was no longer an automatic starter after being sidelined by a heart problem but was still a key figure in the dressing room.

Carrick announced his retirement in 2018 and joined the club’s first-team coaching staff, going on to lead the club to victories over Villarreal and Chelsea following Solskjaer’s sacking in November 2021.

7. Wayne Rooney

Rooney was Louis van Gaal’s natural choice to replace Nemanja Vidic as United captain back in 2014.

“Wayne has shown a great attitude towards everything he does,” Van Gaal said. “I have been very impressed by his professionalism and his attitude to training and to my philosophy.

“He is a great inspiration to the younger members of the team and I believe he will put his heart and soul into his captaincy role.”

However, his time as skipper coincided with United’s struggles after Sir Alex Ferguson’s retirement plus a personal decline in his own performances.

The striker did lift the FA Cup, League Cup and Europa League, but he was increasingly sidelined by Mourinho and returned to boyhood club Everton in 2017.

6. Nemanja Vidic

Vidic is fondly remembered at Old Trafford for his full-blooded approach, and the centre-back formed a superb partnership with Rio Ferdinand.

The Serbian international became United captain in 2011 and led them to their 19th league title that season, as well as the 20th, two years later.

However, Vidic angered some United fans by signing a pre-contract agreement with Inter Milan midway through the 2013-14 season.

5. Steve Bruce

Filling Bryan Robson’s shoes was an almost impossible task, but Bruce stepped up for United and did a brilliant job as captain between 1994 and 1996.

The centre-back grew into a leadership role, and he managed the transition brilliantly, guiding the team to a league and FA Cup double in 1995-96.

We still can’t understand why he was never capped by England.

4. Gary Neville 

Nobody epitomises Manchester United quite like Gary Neville.

The right-back was a boyhood United fan and graduated from the club’s academy, so it was no real surprise when he was given the captaincy after Roy Keane left.

Neville oversaw a renewed period of United dominance between 2005 and 2011, but the defender often had to lead from the bench in the latter stages of his career.

3. Eric Cantona

Cantona didn’t always lead by example but the striker was a cult figure at Old Trafford who led from the front and inspired his team-mates.

Bruce’s move to Birmingham City in 1996 saw the popular decision to give Cantona the armband, and he became the first United captain from outside the United Kingdom or Ireland.

The Frenchman delivered United’s fourth title of the Premier League era and contributed 15 goals in 1996-97 but suddenly retired at the end of the season.

READ: Eric Cantona: One of English football’s greatest ever bargains

2. Bryan Robson

Other Manchester United captains may have won more trophies, but few have been more iconic than Robson.

The midfielder was a natural leader who always put his body on the line, and he was given the captain’s armband by Ron Atkinson in 1982.

United weren’t too successful in the 80s but Robson’s Old Trafford career was crowned with back-to-back Premier League titles in 1993 and 1994.

1. Roy Keane

Keane may have had a controversial exit from Old Trafford in 2005, but don’t forget that the midfielder was once Ferguson’s key lieutenant on the field.

He famously dragged United to a 1999 Champions League semi-final victory over Juventus more or less on his own, despite knowing he would miss the final through suspension.

During his eight years with the armband, Keane helped the Red Devils win four Premier League titles, two FA Cups and a Champions League trophy.

The Irishman may ruffle a few feathers today with his outspoken punditry and willingness to criticise the current crop of players, but anyone that watched Keane play will tell you he’s earned the right to speak his mind.

READ MORE: The week Gary Neville became Man Utd’s deadliest goalscorer

TRY A QUIZ: Can you name Man Utd’s XI from Roy Keane’s debut in 1993?