Tottenham have established themselves as one of the leading forces in the Premier League – but it hasn’t always been this way.
Spurs had only ever finished in the top four of the Premier League twice prior to Mauricio Pochettino’s arrival, both under Harry Redknapp, but the Argentine led them to four consecutive finishes as well as a Champions League final.
There can be no doubt, then, as to who has been the club’s best manager of the Premier League era, but what about the others? Here, we’ve ranked their 13 permanent bosses since 1992 from worst to best.
David Pleat had spent much of the 2003-04 season in temporary charge at White Hart Lane as Spurs spent 10 months searching for the right manager to end their long period of mediocrity.
Daniel Levy was confident Santini, the France manager who it was announced in June 2004 would take over after the European Championship, was that man.
“We haven’t had success for such a long time. It’s a credit to Tottenham we can attract this type of manager,” Levy said.
“I said some time ago that we would make the right appointment – a big name to take the club forward.”
As it turned out, Santini lasted only 13 games before resigning, reportedly due to a falling-out with Director of Football Frank Arnesen. After witnessing just six goals in 11 league games, Spurs fans weren’t too disappointed.
12. Juande Ramos
It may very well be a tad harsh that the last manager to actually win silverware in charge of Spurs is ranked as their second worst manager of the past 26 years, but that 2008 League Cup win was simply a thin spreading of butter in a sh*t sandwich.
In fairness, he steered the team from 18th to 11th after taking over from Martin Jol in October 2007, but a year later he was sacked with the side in an even worse position than the one he had inherited: bottom, four points adrift, with two points from eight games.
His reign ended following an apparent dressing room revolt, with his assistant Gus Poyet and sporting director Damien Comolli also sacked in an admission of a very expensive mistake by Daniel Levy.
Ramos was, however, the man in charge when Luka Modric was brought to the club, so it wasn’t all bad.
If Spurs’ first season in the Premier League was cheese on toast – boring but satisfactory – their second season under Ardilles was cheese on a roast dinner – it was definitely different and definitely exciting to try, but ultimately it didn’t work.
With five players often fielded in attack, Spurs were undoubtedly a lot of fun to watch, but it sadly didn’t pay off as Spurs actually scored less goals than they had managed the previous season, finishing way down in 15th.
The signing of Jurgen Klinsmann in 1994 clearly convinced Ardiles he could make his philosophy work, with the German scoring three times in his first two appearances, but he was sacked in November with Spurs having conceded 24 goals in 12 league games.
Gross was appointed in November 1997 with Spurs in the relegation zone on the back of a 4-0 thrashing at Liverpool in their previous game.
Alarm bells should have rung when he arrived late for his first press conference holding a tube ticket with ”my ticket to the dreams” written on it, and a 6-1 home defeat to Chelsea in Gross’ third game in charge did little to quell the feeling he was a man out of his depth.
The return of Jurgen Klinsmann in December was enough to steer the club clear of relegation – the German top scored with nine goals in the Premier League as Spurs finished 14th – but John Scales later revealed Gross was “ridiculed by the players behind closed doors”.
His eccentricity was a dream for the press but certainly not the club, and the only surprise was that he started the following season in charge before the traditional disastrous start saw him sacked.
Graham was unpopular when he got the job having previously managed Arsenal, and unpopular when he left having leaked confidential information to the press.
His style of play didn’t win him too many fans in the interim period either, though he did lead them to League Cup victory in 1999. Finishing 11th and 10th hardly helped matters.
Spurs had failed to finish higher than 10th for five seasons when Hoddle took charge in 2001, so a ninth-placed finish and run to the League Cup final was a clear step in the right direction in his first campaign.
Unfortunately, the exciting new era fans had hoped for under the legendary player failed to materialise as they dropped back to 10th the following season before Hoddle was sacked in September 2003 following one win and four defeats from the opening six league games.
The style of football was certainly more palatable than his predecessor George Graham’s, but actual success rarely looked likely under the former England manager.
Spurs finished eighth in the inaugural Premier League season under the joint management of Livermore of Clemence, a vast improvement on 15th the year before.
The signings of Teddy Sheringham and Darren Anderton would benefit the club for several years, but an FA Cup semi-final defeat to Arsenal stung, and it came as no surprise to anyone when Spurs looked to add some excitement in the form of Ardilles…
— Spurs Nostalgia (@thfcnostalgia) July 13, 2015
Having finished 15th under Ardilles in 1993-94, Spurs were struggling again the following season when the Argentine was sacked and replaced by Francis.
They eventually finished seventh, their best finish for five years, and reached the semi-finals of the FA Cup, with Jurgen Klinsmann scoring 30 goals in a very entertaining, very Spurs season.
Unfortunately, Francis couldn’t keep it up once Klinsmann left as Spurs finished eighth and then 10th before Francis resigned in November 1997 with the team in the relegation zone.
If we were ranking these managers on their Premier League win percentage, Sherwood would be No.1. As he memorably said himself, a 59% win ratio is “second to none”.
Unfortunately for Tim, it was comments like that, combined with rumours that he got the job in an underhand way – and then some strange tactical decisions once he did – which prevented Spurs fans from really taking to him.
Still, he took the team from seventh to sixth in his half-season in charge while promoting youth and, in case you didn’t know, giving Harry Kane his first Premier League start. He wasn’t all bad.
– The man solely responsible for Harry Kane: ✅
– Second to none win ratio: ✅
– Greatest manager of all time: ✅
— The Sportsman (@TheSportsman) February 6, 2018
Taking over from Redknapp after Spurs had finished fourth but been denied a Champions League place courtesy of Chelsea winning the competition, Villas-Boas got his own taste of misfortune in his only full season in charge as a then-record Premier League points tally still wasn’t enough to get them into the top four.
Their 72 points in 2012-13 was actually more than Spurs managed when finishing third under Pochettino three years later, and though the Portuguese manager undoubtedly benefitted from Gareth Bale’s incredible form, it was a hugely entertaining season.
It’s also worth pointing out Hugo Lloris, Jan Vertonghen, Mousa Dembele and Christian Eriksen were all signed during his time in charge.
Jol had initially been appointed as First Assistant Coach to Santini in the summer of 2004, but it only took 12 games before he was thrust into the hotseat himself.
In fairness, it was not difficult to be more popular than Santini, but Jol’s personality quickly endeared him to Spurs supporters – and more importantly, so did the team’s improvement under his stewardship.
After finishing ninth in that 2004-05 season, five places higher than the previous year, Jol steered Spurs to fifth twice in a row, their best placing of the Premier League era, including in 2006 when they were fourth going into the final game only for a dodgy lasagna to famously wreck their preparations.
‘Arry has always been a figure of fun for some people, incapable of turning on a computer or actually bothering with any, yer know, actual tactics.
But he certainly got the best out of the Spurs squad during his near-four seasons in charge, taking over a team that had suffered the club’s worst ever start to a season and steering them to eighth and the League Cup final before leading them to fourth in two of his other three years in charge.
There was also that memorable run to the Champions League quarter-finals in 2011. Football is as much about memories as it is results, and Redknapp created plenty of those.
Spurs reaching a Champions League final seemed unthinkable when Pochettino replaced Tim Sherwood.
Having failed to win a trophy in his five seasons in charge, it’ll be interesting to see how history treats him, but those in there here and now should not forget the team he inherited.