Not the best. Or the worst. The weirdest.

Ranking the 13 weirdest American signings in Premier League history

It’s strange to think that the old US of A plays football with their feet now, but the game is growing at an incredible pace in the States and so too is the number of Americans arriving on European shores to play professionally.

But there’s a rich history of American footballers in England, playing to varying degrees of success. We all know about the best and worst American players to have turned out in the Premier League, but what about the weirdest?

Without further ado, here are the 13 weirdest Americans to ever play in the Premier League, ordered and selected based on our stringent formula and definitely not purely on which ones made us laugh the most.

13. Michael Bradley

Former Aston Villa player Bradley takes up the unlucky 13th spot on our list.

He signed for Villa on loan from Borussia Monchengladbach for half a season back in 2011 but made just three appearances and was labelled a flop.

But he went on enjoy an illustrious career when he returned to his home continent, captaining both Toronto and the USMNT and making over 400 appearances for the two combined.

A few years ago Villa fans couldn’t believe that the US national was the third-highest earner in the MLS, behind only Kaka and Sebastian Giovinco. He probably did more than both put together in his domestic league to be fair.

12. Kasey Keller

Why do people enjoy being a goalkeeper? For Keller… well he didn’t.

Keller joined Spurs in 2001 from Rayo Vallecano but also played for Southampton, Leicester, Fulham and Millwall at various points over his career.

“I really didn’t realise what a horrible position it was until it was too late,” Keller recalled.

He stuck with it though, his career spanning 22 years, starting and finishing in the US.

READ: A head-first dive into the wild west world of MLS mascots

11. Marcus Hahnemann

When you think of the ‘ideal’ American pastimes what do you think of?

Hunting? Fishing on some huge lake? Maybe some thrill-seeker activity like skiing?

Well funnily enough that’s how former Fulham, Reading, Wolves, and Everton goalkeeper Hahnemann spends his retirement. Those past times have seen him labelled an “All-American hero” by Reading. Seattle-born and bred, he started and finished his career with the Sounders. That’s nice.

10. Geoff Cameron

Before playing for Stoke and QPR, Cameron played for both the Rhode Island Stingrays and the Rhode Island Rams in what we can only assume is the most hotly contested animal-based Derby in the US.

But the reason Cameron is on this list is not for swapping Stingrays for Rams.

Footballers nowadays are not afraid to voice their opinion on social issues and politics and that’s genuinely a good thing, with players able to use their platform to increase public knowledge on an important issue.

Unless you’re a raging Donald Trump supporter that is.

Cameron’s been vocal in his support for the former President, especially when he suspended immigration from majority-Islamic countries.

As you can imagine he was hugely slated for his opinions and he hasn’t said much since. Back in 2022, he was unable to go over the border to Canada for games because he won’t get vaccinated. Good.

9. Oguchi Onyewu

Onyewu had a six-month stint in the Premier League with Newcastle in 2007.

He formed a centre-back partnership with Titus Bramble which still gives the Newcastle fan in our office nightmares.

Widely regarded as one of the worst in Premier League history, the two made a number of comedic-level mistakes.

The loan was never made permanent, unsurprisingly, and he’s now sporting director at Orlando City’s B team.

8. John Harkes

We had to include the first American ever to play in the Premier League.

Harkes joined Sheffield Wednesday in 1990, joining from the very American-ly names “Albany Capitals”.

That means he technically wasn’t a prem signing, but we had to include him anyway.

He stayed with Wednesday until 1993 when he moved to Derby.

Outside of football he’s probably best known for being dropped from the 1998 US World Cup squad not for footballing reasons, but for having an affair with his team-mate’s wife. Of course, when Harkes published his autobiography he didn’t mention it.

7. Jermaine Jones

Jones joined Blackburn Rovers for six months in 2011 from Schalke.

He became a firm fan favourite at Ewood Park and when he returned to Germany he became a regular under now-United manager Ralf Rangnick.

He’s on here for one reason and one reason only; he’s a US indoor football international.

Jones played for the “United States National Arena Soccer Team”, to give it its full name, a year after he left club football.

Indoor football? If they allow very frequent pauses to down Lucozade Sport and catch your breath we reckon we’d be alright at that.

6. Johann Smith

They say learning should never stop, and former Bolton player Smith took that to heart.

He made just the one Prem appearance for Bolton and now studies at Stanford, which we think inspired Bolton’s stadium to change its name to the University of Bolton stadium.

Stanford might not quite have the same level of academic reputation as Bolton, but that hasn’t stopped Smith from studying history there since his retirement.

“I’ve lived one life already; I’ve lived one dream,” Smith said,

“Now I’m here to realize another.”

But here’s the thing, he’s studying history in order to become a medical doctor.

“As a doctor, I’ll need to understand the history of the people I am serving and the country we live in.

“The medical field benefits from humanities majors who approach medicine from unique perspectives.”

If our doctor had studied history before going to medical school and before that was a pro footballer we’d probably listen more too.

Fulham's Clint Dempsey celebrates his goal during their Premier League draw against West Ham United at Upton Park, London, October 2010.

TRY A QUIZ: Can you name every player from the USA to score in the Premier League?

5. Cobi Jones

Imagine becoming famous because of your hair? Well, that’s kind of what happened to Jones.

The midfielder played one season for Coventry in the Prem in 1994-95 after impressing at the ’94 World Cup, but his escapades in the following year’s Copa America saw him become a sensation in South America for his hair as well as his ability.

He became known as “Escobillon” for his hair meaning ‘swab’, and such was his popularity he played a single season in Brazil for Vasco de Gama in 1995-96.

He then returned to the US for the inaugural MLS season and is the US national team’s most capped player ever.

4. Maurice Edu

Edu made just one appearance for Stoke in the Premier League in 2012.

His career mainly took place in the US, which would explain why, when Jamie Carragher was on punditry duty with him, the Liverpool legend was caught googling his colleague to find out who he actually was.

He took it in good humour of course, probably because when he googled Carragher he found plenty to laugh at as well.

3. Ian Feuer

Many sports starts, especially in America, end up going into Movies and TV.

None will have as good a credit as goalkeeper Feuer however, who played for several English teams in the Prem and lower leagues through his career.

He had a cameo appearance in Kicking and Screaming, basically a ‘Soccer’ version of The Mighty Ducks.

An absolute classic, starring Will Ferrell. If you missed it in your childhood it’s probably worth a watch now, especially if you try to spot Feuer.

2. Lynden Gooch

Americans often have some frankly bizarre names, Brick and Chad come to mind for examples.

But look, we’d love to tell you there’s a more mature reason than his surname for Sunderland’s Gooch to be in here but there isn’t.

Don’t deny it, you know it’s funny.

1. Preki

There are many reasons Preki deserves the number one spot, but simply put it’s his long career swapping normal football for the indoor version.

Everton actually signed him from an indoor side, St Louis Storm, in 1992 and believe it or not he wasn’t able to successfully transition from Futsal to the Premier League.

Everton sold him back to another indoor team, the San Jose Grizzlies, but that wasn’t enough to put Portsmouth off of bringing him back to normal football and England in 1994 although he left in 1995 to go to… the San Jose Grizzlies.

He had a long MLS career after that and has been a coach and manager since he retired.

In fact, in 2015 he left his role at one US club expecting to be announced as Leicester City manager, only for Claudio Ranieri to get the job. Apparently, Preki’s insistence they train in the hall at the local leisure centre didn’t go down well.

READ NEXT: ‘Pele changed everything’: Werner Roth tells the story of the NY Cosmos

TRY A QUIZ: Can you name every player to score 10+ goals for the USMNT?