Antony & the 18 other Man Utd debut scorers in the Premier League era
Manchester United have a long history of world-class footballers but only a select few players have scored on their debut for the club.
Antony is the latest player to score on his first appearance for the Red Devils. The £85million Brazilian scored the opening goal against Arsenal, having been entrusted against Erik ten Hag to go straight into the starting line-up just days after his arrival from Ajax.
But a strong start isn’t always a signal of great times ahead. Some players build on that moment and have a long and successful United career, while others struggle to replicate it and fall by the wayside.
We’ve looked back at the 18 other players who scored on their competitive United debut in the Premier League era and noted how they subsequently fared.
Scholes was part of the famous class of 92 at Old Trafford but concerns over his size meant that he didn’t make his first-team debut until September 1994.
The midfielder started against Port Vale in the League Cup and scored twice in a 2-1 win before scoring on his league debut against Ipswich Town three days later.
He never really looked back after that and won 11 Premier League titles over the next 19 years, scoring 155 goals in 718 appearances.
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer
Solskjaer was signed from Molde in 1996 but had to wait until United’s third league game of the season to make his debut.
The Norwegian was subbed on in the 64th minute against Blackburn Rovers and found the back six minutes later to secure a 2-2 draw.
He continued to score goals as a super sub throughout his United career, most notably the winner against Bayern Munich in the 1999 Champions League final. Dunno what he’s up to these days.
Ruud Van Nistelrooy
United were set to sign Van Nistelrooy in 2000 only for injuries to delay the move. They finally got their man a year later and it was definitely worth the wait.
The striker made his competitive debut in the 2001 FA Charity Shield, although his second-half goal wasn’t enough to stop United losing to Liverpool.
He followed that up with a double on his league debut and continued to impress by scoring 150 goals in 219 appearances before joining Real Madrid in 2006.
United opted to boost their firepower in 2004 by signing prolific Fulham forward Saha during the January transfer window, and he was thrown in from the start against Southampton.
He scored the opener after 18 minutes when his free-kick from the edge of the area took a wild deflection and hit the back of the net.
The striker bagged another six league goals that season but started to struggle with injury problems and joined Everton in 2008 after losing his place in the team.
United spent £27million to bring Rooney to Old Trafford but fans had to wait for a glimpse of their new signing while he recovered from a broken metatarsal that scuppered England’s chances at Euro 2004.
Rooney finally made his much-anticipated debut against Fenerbahce in the Champions League group stage and didn’t disappoint.
He grabbed a remarkable hat-trick but that was just the start. Rooney scored another 250 goals for the club over the next 13 years to become their top goalscorer of all time.
🗓 28 September 2004
🏟 Old Trafford
On this day in 2004, an 18-year-old Wayne Rooney scored a devastating hat-trick in his first game for Manchester United.
A debut to remember! 🔴 pic.twitter.com/CN9ZQldaSB
— Football on BT Sport (@btsportfootball) September 28, 2019
Heinze joined United from PSG in 2004 but missed United’s first four league games of the season due to his participation in the Olympics with Argentina.
The defender made up for lost time by scoring against Bolton on his debut and his performances saw him win the United’s Players’ Player of the Year award in his debut season.
But Heinze later angered United supporters by trying to force a transfer to Liverpool in 2007 and was eventually sold to Real Madrid instead.
The midfielder progressed through United’s academy and came off the bench to score the winner against Crewe Alexandra in the League Cup on his first-team debut.
Lee only ever made one appearance in the Premier League, receiving a guard of honour from the Chelsea players after United had won the league in 2007.
Now 31, he left for Oldham on a free transfer in 2008 and has spent the last seven and a half years at Sheffield Wednesday.
With United losing 2-1 against Aston Villa in April 2009, Ferguson decided to take a gamble and brought on an untried 17-year-old.
Cristiano Ronaldo got the equaliser before Macheda conjured up a stunning 92nd-minute winner to swing the title race back in United’s favour.
“To this moment, it remains the best football day of my life,” Macheda told ESPN in 2017.
“I woke up and I was on the front page of newspapers all around the world. My friends were calling me from Rome and crying down the phone. I went into training and all the staff were high-fiving me and saying well done.
The striker was unable to hit those same heights again and left the club in 2014 having made only 36 first-team appearances.
— Premier League (@premierleague) April 5, 2016
United identified Buttner as Patrice Evra’s long-term replacement, and it seemed like they had got a bargain when he went on a mazy run to score on his debut against Wigan.
However, that was about as good as it got for the left-back, who went on to make another 12 Premier League appearances before joining Russian side Dynamo Moscow in 2014.
Just like Buttner, Powell also scored on his debut against Wigan, and he didn’t fare much better either.
“Nick Powell is going to be a really good player,” Ferguson said after the game against Wigan. “He has a great temperament, is two-footed and quick. He is a good physical specimen and has terrific vision.
“We hope Powell fills Paul Scholes’ boots. For an 18-year-old boy it has been a terrific day.”
However, that would be his only goal in a United shirt during four years at Old Trafford as the midfielder was eventually released in 2016.
Wilson was a highly-rated young talent and was handed his debut by Ryan Giggs in United’s penultimate game of the 2013-14 season.
The striker scored twice against Hull City, but his progression was hampered by a serious knee injury. Nowadays he’s turning out for Port Vale after failing to live up to that early promise.
Martial was thrown into the deep end after his big-money move from Monaco, coming on for Juan Mata in the second half of a tense meeting with Liverpool in September 2015.
With score at 2-1 with five minutes remaining, the forward scored a brilliant goal to clinch the victory and became a cult hero at Old Trafford.
“That was a very big game, both for me and the team,” Martial told United Review in 2018.
“I think it’s my most important goal so far. It’s the goal that really announced my arrival and the goal that gave me that strength to be able to establish myself at United from the word go.”
He’s had plenty of moments over the years and there’s renewed hope that Ten Hag can get him firing again, but he’s scored one league goal in the last 18 months. Not what you’d have expected seven years ago.
📆 #OnThisDay September 12, 2015
Anthony Martial made his Man Utd debut and scored this wondergoal vs Liverpool 🔥pic.twitter.com/gp4ZSo43gj
— GOAL (@goal) September 12, 2019
Rashford was set to be on the bench against FC Midtjylland in 2016, but was elevated to the starting XI after Martial was injured in the warm-up.
He made the most of the opportunity by scoring twice and then got another double on his Premier League debut against Arsenal three days later.
The 24-year-old has since established himself as a regular England international and is closing in on a century of goals for his boyhood club, but like Martial it’s been a long time since he enjoyed a decent run of form.
Ibrahimovic joined on a free transfer in the summer of 2016 and made an instant impact, scoring an 83rd-minute winner in the Community Shield against Leicester City.
The striker was a revelation in his debut season in England, scoring 28 goals in 46 appearances as the Red Devils won the League Cup and the Europa League.
However, a serious knee injury curtailed his United career and Ibrahimovic signed for LA Galaxy in 2018.
Harrop made his United debut against Crystal Palace in 2017 as the team prepared for the Europa League final and scored the opener in a 2-0 win.
That proved to be his one and only appearance for the club as the 24-year-old rejected a new deal and signed for Preston immediately afterwards.
Lukaku had an amazing start to his United career and scored 11 goals in his first 10 appearances in 2017-18, including a debut strike against Real Madrid in the UEFA Super Cup.
The striker scored 42 goals in 96 appearances for the club but fell down the pecking order under Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and was sold to Inter Milan in 2019.
James was a surprise signing from Swansea City in 2019, but he answered any critics by coming off the bench and scoring United’s fourth goal in an emphatic 4-0 win over Chelsea.
“I don’t think you could write it, really,” James said after the full-time whistle.
“As soon as I signed here, I dreamed of something like that to happen and it did today. To score on my debut and to win 4-0 at Old Trafford in the first game, no, I don’t think you could (imagine that).”
The winger then scored two goals in his next three appearances but never quite showed the quality required. He’s one of the few played United have sold at a profit in recent years, but he also struggled to convince at Leeds United and is now out on loan at Fulham.
Daniel James’ goal vs Chelsea (4-0) pic.twitter.com/TqN1oucVrp
— United Goals ⚽️ (@UnitedGoals__) August 11, 2019
Donny van de Beek
The only goal in a 3-1 defeat to Crystal Palace. The story of his United career.
Watch this space.