When Mesut Özil produced a man-of-the-match performance against Tottenham in November, it could have been viewed as one in the eye for those who say he doesn’t do it in the big games. But for some, what Özil does will never be enough.
Less than 20 minutes into the North London derby, Aaron Ramsey played one of those passes that reminds you how far 99% of other players are from possessing Premier League quality.
Had Alexandre Lacazette managed to find the net from the resulting Hector Bellerín cutback, we might have found ourselves talking about it for weeks to come.
Even with the Frenchman’s failure to do so, Ramsey’s performance would normally be one to which plenty of column inches are devoted.
However, he had the misfortune of putting in an 8/10 display in a game where Mesut Özil was in 10/10 form.
Perhaps it’s due to the £52million arrival of Lacazette ensuring he no longer has that record signing pressure in the biggest games, but the German has shown again this season that he is capable of running the show like few of his peers.
Sure, Tottenham may have erred by leaving Harry Winks out of their starting line-up and trading intense pressure without the ball for intense pressure on it, but that should not take away from Özil’s input.
45 – Since his debut in Sept 2013, Mesut Ozil has provided more assists in the Premier League than any other player (45). Delivery. pic.twitter.com/BL1msF4QMt
— OptaJoe (@OptaJoe) November 18, 2017
A magnet for criticism
On plenty of occasions since Özil’s big-money arrival from Real Madrid, observers have seen opposition players put in a virtuoso performance and wondered aloud why the Arsenal man wasn’t doing the same.
What can be more frustrating, however, is the occasional decision to respond to better performances with complaints that he isn’t producing the goods more regularly.
For Özil, it’s almost never ‘that’s what he’s capable of.’ Rather than ‘that’s what he’s capable of, but…’.
Part of that can be put down to the price tag, and it can be hard for fans to shake the concept that £42million is a lot of money, even when inflated fees have seen the club throw almost as much at Shkodran Mustafi and Granit Xhaka.
Perhaps Özil started too quickly, setting up all three goals in a win over Stoke in September 2013. Often the worst thing a player can do is raise expectations with stats as well as performances, because that will make it easier to downplay the latter when the former doesn’t match up.
However, one thing which often isn’t raised quite as much is the ability to conjure a breakthrough which would not be forthcoming without Özil’s input, as was the case against Spurs.
This, in its own way, only serves to highlight the more disappointing displays – often, when Özil is off his game, it can filter through to the rest of the team as they attempt unsuccessfully to stretch play and attempt low-margin passes and shots out of frustration – but it’s rarely balanced out with praise for match-winning performances which others would not have been capable of.
There’s no denying the free-kick for the hosts opener was soft, with Davinson Sánchez arguably winning the ball cleanly from his namesake Alexis, but Özil’s ball to the Chilean had set up that situation, and it was his delivery to the (admittedly offside) Mustafi that brought the goal.
It was also Özil who had got in behind earlier on one of those rare occasions Sánchez was powerless to stop an attack, only to be pulled back for an equally soft foul on Jan Vertonghen.
But, hey, we’re falling into that same trap again, judging Özil only on the big-ticket moments when that was far from his only input.
Mustafi’s goal putting us 1-0 up!pic.twitter.com/9unuEKkHS4
— IDontLikeSpurs (@IDontLikeSpurs) November 18, 2017
When he’s on his game, Özil is one of those players who always seems to have an extra second on the ball. He’s That Jack Wilshere Performance Against Barcelona made flesh.
A reliance on big performances at the point a player has been all but written off is hardly the most sustainable approach, but a refusal to acknowledge Özil as more special than his peers could yet be enough for him to remind us he’s still alive and kicking.
During his title-winning season in Madrid, he shone in a squad which also boasted Cristiano Ronaldo, Karim Benzema, Gonzalo Higuaín and Ángel Di Maria, a scenario which forced him to muck in and to make his opportunities to showcase his attacking instincts really count.
While many can point to assist stats, or lack thereof, that campaign demonstrated there is more than one way of setting up your team-mates for greatness, even if it requires input from both sides.
— Mesut Özil (@MesutOzil1088) November 18, 2017
Özil’s perceived struggles could be compared to those facing Paul Pogba in his first season back at Manchester United, with underwhelming team-mates or a lack of cohesion resulting in the rare moments of magic producing no tangible reward.
When a player is capable of making the game look so easy, fans will undoubtedly be frustrated on the occasions he seems to find the going that bit tougher, but this would be less of an issue were he not the only one at the club capable of some of the things he does.
He may never fully convince his doubters that peak Özil can or has returned, but just enjoy the fact that he can still come to the phone, and – as he showed against Spurs – he might even pick up even when you’ve dialled the wrong number.
By Tom Victor